Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Keira Andrews's avatar

This is so disappointing. The anti-trans moral panic is ABSURD. This is not a problem. It has never been a problem. And Navratilova's descent into TERF radicalism is destroying her legacy. (At least in my eyes.)

Charles Arthur's avatar

Two things. First, this makes sense in the light of the IOC decision to adopt SRY screening (as it is correctly called: because the check for SRY is a first step, and CAIS and Swyer syndrome are exceptions which allow participation in the female category). The IOC adopted it because it couldn’t ignore the effects of not doing SRY screening - as it had in 1992 and 1996 - when Imane Khelif, who is an XY male with 5-ARD (see the Wikipedia page), same as Caster Semenya, won in the female category in boxing. that put female opponents at serious risk because males can punch much harder for the same weight than women; it is due to testosterone and other birth advantages.

Khelif is emphatically not trans, but is male; wrongly thought to be female at birth.

Second, you write: “because biological sex is not as purely binary as many assume”. This is wrong. Biological sex is absolutely binary: male and female. Phenotypes (the bodily appearance) vary a lot but even with DSDs (eg Khelif, Semenya) one can determine a sex, and that sex is only male or female, based on whether they have a body organised for making sperm or ova (even if they don’t produce any). In wrong what you did, you’re straying into a field that is frequently misreported. Please don’t.

In doing this, the WTA is joining athletics, boxing, cycling, swimming and winter sports (under the FIS), triathlon, rowing and some others I may have forgotten. This is not an outlier; it’s a return to a technology that was understood and used in 1992, but whose use was stopped *gainst the wishes of female athletes* in 1999 by the IOC on advice which, in retrospect, was unscientific.

It’s a cheek swab, in case anyone was wondering. Quick, fast, only needs to be done once and gives everyone confidence about their opponent. A lot less intrusive than dope testing.

28 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?